Before the team can send out their updated message, they’ll need to find a way to broadcast it. That’s because the telescope at the Arecibo Observatory suffered structural damage and collapsed in 2020. Scientists would need to modify another large telescope to make the transmission. The team already has potential telescope options in mind. But first, they want to share their message with the public. “We are not planning to send this out until everybody agrees,” says Jiang. “We want to encourage an open discussion and remind people that they are all citizens of Earth.”
Not everyone is excited about trying to communicate with aliens. “Some people think it is dangerous to give aliens information about our existence,” says Chris Impey, an astronomer at the University of Arizona. What if the aliens we contact aren’t peaceful? Some believe “it’s safer to just listen for signals from a distant civilization and then decide whether to reply,” Impey says.
But like it or not, we’ve already been broadcasting our presence for more than a century—ever since radio was invented. “Any civilization capable of traveling to Earth can already pick up those accidental TV and radio signals,” says Vakoch. “Sending intentional signals into space doesn’t increase the risk of extraterrestrials knowing we’re here—it just lets them know we want to start a conversation.”
Still, this conversation probably won’t take place anytime soon. The Arecibo message, for example, won’t arrive at its target for another 25,000 years. And if any aliens happen to detect that message, decode it, and send a reply, it would take thousands of years for their response to get back to Earth.
So far, scientists haven’t found any signs of alien life—peaceful or otherwise. But that doesn’t mean there isn’t life out there. The universe is big, after all. “It’s a great question: ‘Are we alone?’ We don’t know yet,” says Jiang. “Maybe our children, or our children’s children, will make that discovery.” Until then, scientists will continue to watch the skies.